India’s GST 2.0: A Bold Tax Overhaul with Mixed Fortunes

5 days ago
3 min read

India’s GST 2.0: A Bold Tax Overhaul with Mixed Fortunes

Overview of the Reform

India’s government has ushered in its most sweeping GST reform since 2017—dubbed GST 2.0—to simplify tax slabs, reduce burdens on common consumers, and spur economic activity. Some of the key elements include:

Simplified slab structure: Replaced the existing four-tier system (5%, 12%, 18%, 28%) with just 5% and 18%, plus a 40% “demerit” rate for luxury and sin goods.
Effective from 22 September 2025, aligning with the festive season (Navratri/Diwali).

Major tax reductions include:

Essentials such as milk, paneer, roti, packaged foods, and medicines now taxed at 5% or exempt (nil).
Consumer durables (ACs, TVs, appliances), cement, small vehicles, and auto parts have seen GST drop from 28% to 18%.
Life and health insurance, life-saving medications, medical devices now zero-rated or lowered to 5%.
Farm equipment, tractors, fertilizers, handicrafts, and renewable energy devices have also moved to the 5% bracket.
Luxury/sin goods (tobacco, pan masala, high-end cars, etc.) now attract 40% GST on retail sale price, tightening regulation.

Beyond rate changes, procedural reforms are also part of the overhaul:

Easier registration, risk-based provisional refunds (up to 90% for zero-rated supplies), and the new GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) operational from September/December 2025 to handle disputes faster.
Exporters benefit from simplified tax handling, location-based service taxation, and removal of low-value refund limits.
Enhanced e-invoicing, e-way bill restrictions, MFA (multi-factor authentication), invoice-level reporting, and ISD requirements for ITC—all aiming to improve transparency.

Pros of the GST Reforms

1. Consumer Relief & Boost to Demand

The reduction or removal of GST on staples and healthcare essentials will directly lower household expenses, easing inflation by up to 1.1 percentage point.

2. Stimulus for Economic Growth

By cutting taxes on hundreds of goods—including appliances, cars, cement, and food items—the reforms are expected to boost consumption during festive spending. Retail giants like Amber Enterprises and Trent are poised to benefit.

3. Support for Key Sectors

MSMEs, agriculture, construction, healthcare, and renewable energy stand to gain from cheaper inputs and tax relief.
Cement tax cuts reduce construction input costs substantially, aiding infrastructure affordability.
Healthcare access improves with life-saving drugs and insurance tax relief.

4. Improved Compliance & Dispute Resolution

Simplified slabs reduce classification confusion.
Tools like GSTAT, provisional refunds, and ease in e-filing promote better compliance and dispute mitigation.

Cons & Concerns

1. Revenue Loss & Fiscal Pressure

The government anticipates a loss of ₹48,000 crore (~$5.5 billion), potentially stretching state budgets.
Compensation concerns, especially for states like Kerala, remain unresolved.

2. Sectoral Discontent—Gold & Jewellery

Jewelers face continued “tax-on-tax”, applying 3% GST on gold and 5% additional on making charges, causing double taxation and pushing traders to the informal market.

3. Compliance Burden on Businesses

Digital mandates like MFA, e-invoicing, invoice-level reporting may overwhelm small businesses without adequate tools.

4. External Risks Could Offset Gains

Despite the consumer-friendly policy, trade tensions and US tariffs pose risks; institutional experts warn of offsetting effects.

5. Possible Overlook: R&D Support for Defence MSMEs

Some startups lament 18% tax on MoD grants, seeing it as disincentivizing innovation, even as government institutions are exempt.

Summary Table: Pros vs Cons

Pros	Cons
Lower prices for essentials	Revenue loss (~₹48,000 crore)
Stimulus for consumer & retail demand	Budget strain on states
Support to key growth sectors	Gold/jewellery double taxation persists
Stronger compliance & appeal systems	Increased compliance costs for SMEs
Access to justice via GSTAT	Risk of offset by global economic threats
Better export facilitation	Innovation in defence facing tax barriers

Final Thoughts

India’s GST 2.0 signals a dramatic shift toward a simpler, fairer, and growth-oriented tax regime—one that delivers relief to everyday consumers and empowers key economic sectors. It's a strategic move aligned with festive momentum, consumer sentiment, and digital modernization. However, balancing fiscal sustainability, equitable treatment of sectors, and export resilience remains vital for the long-term success of these reforms.